Directed by Lynn Shelton
Starring Mark Duplass, Emily Blunt, Rosemarie Dewitt
Grade B-
I hesitate to call this movie a hipster romance due to the vehement attention that word gets and the fact that it’s now become every bit as cliché to rip on hipsters as it is to actually be one. Nobody wins with that word anymore. Though allow me to digress on that a moment. White people can’t stand being referred to as a hipster, in fact they seem to get mortally offended by the accusation. It’s become some sort of racial slur against the self-consciously hip white crowd, though I think it’s fair to keep in mind that most other races in this country deal with far more cutting and vicious slurs than hipster. Just food for thought next time you get enraged that someone uses “that word” referring to you when you drop references to obscure authors and say things like “I liked their early stuff.” Okay, digression over. Anyway, Your Sister’s Sister is about grown white people living in Seattle who ride bikes and are intelligent and read a lot and are generally slacking their way through life. When you break it down, this movie is really a pretty simple romantic comedy with just enough quirk thrown in to get away with it.
The basic plot is this: Jack is sad about his brother’s death a year ago and is drinking too much and acting like an asshole everywhere he goes. His best friend Iris, who it shouldn’t be much of a surprise is in love with him, sends him up to her family’s cabin where he can be alone and get his mind straight. When he gets there, though, Iris’ lesbian sister Hannah is already there, trying to come to grips with the fact that she just walked out of a 7 year, destructive relationship. Jack and Hannah have drunken, awkward sex and naturally Iris shows up the next day and everybody struggles with just how much information they should share with everybody else. Also, Hannah may or may not have used Jack in order to get his sperm so she can get pregnant.
Individually, pretty much every scene in this film is enjoyable. The always charming Mark Duplass plays Jack and is funny and jaded, at one point giving an awkwardly hilarious-yet-tragic monologue about his dead brother’s shortcomings as a human being at what’s supposed to be a celebration of his life. He brings this same tone to the rest of the movie and is consistently enjoyable to watch. The entire cast, Duplass, Emily Blunt and Rosemarie Dewitt, all play well off each other and bring life to all the dialogue, which sounds natural and unforced. The moments that are played for laughs get them and the moments that are aiming for uncomfortable achieve it just fine. The problem is that, while they all work individually, they don’t quite add up to anything particularly remarkable. Everything works out about as well as you’d think, and even the bit of a cliffhanger at the end doesn’t come off as terribly important. Nobody seems to really come to terms with any of the shit they’ve been dealing with, but everyone seems pretty much okay with that. That they become a sort of makeshift family is nice and all but I’m not sure it totally earns that feeling.
This is a movie that I punish more for what it could be rather than what it is. The cast assembled is great and they obviously have some passion for the material, and writer/director Lynn Shelton has a very good ear for dialogue. It just doesn’t quite achieve what I think it was capable of and that’s unfortunate. Whether that’s fair or not, I can’t say, but thems my thoughts.




